Skip to Content

Apple engineers: We're indentured servants

On Monday, a group of Apple technical staffers filed suit against Apple alleging that the company denied them overtime pay and meal compensation. Both the pay and meal compensation are required by California state law. The suit also claims that many Apple employees are subjected to working conditions that are similar to indentured servitude.

The lead plaintiff in the lawsuit, David Walsh, was an Apple network engineer from 1995 to 2007. He stated that he was often required to work more than 40 hours a week, miss meals, and spend evenings and weekends on call without any overtime pay or meal compensation. [Author's personal comment: this is not unusual in the tech industry]

Walsh alleges that Apple deliberately classified Walsh and others as management employees so that they would not receive overtime compensation as required by California law for hourly employees. The class action suit also seeks to include the staffers at Apple Stores as plaintiffs.

Should the plaintiffs win, Apple could be required to revise its compensation practices and pay retroactive compensation to many present and past employees. Apple has not responded to the complaint.

Thanks to Charles for the tip!

On Monday, a group of Apple technical staffers filed suit against Apple alleging that the company denied them overtime pay and meal...
 

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

83 Comments

Filter by:
Josh

It almost makes sense at this point, this is why companies are moving all of their business overseas. Working more than 40 hours in the IT field has been standard practice for several years anyway.

Dell is on their way to the phillipines, apple soon to follow. GG guys.

August 09 2008 at 1:00 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Wade

The dodo, the 8 hr day, the 40 hour work week, and for the most part overtime pay...

techy me

August 08 2008 at 10:59 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Joe

I guess a company in this situation has the choice to settle the claim and then outsource those jobs to India. Sounds like a bad alternative to me, but hey, what's how it goes?

August 08 2008 at 12:52 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
KiL

You Americans are a funky bunch. I mean what are your labour laws for if not for the people working. And then you say "you don't like the working rules? Go work for someone else."

Well let me tell you something, those working rules are cleary set out in your friggin' law and the only one who doesn't seem to like those "working rules" are some big companies who think they can endorse certain laws and ignore others as they see fit. If the real situtation is that al of your employers are breaking the law, then don't blame the little man who ask them to stick to those laws for a change.

August 08 2008 at 12:10 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Brian Peat

august08:

It wasn't the corporations that convinced me that Unions are a big joke these days, it was the WORKERS themselves. I worked a big show in St. Louis a few years back at the arena there. We had to pay 2 guys to sit through the show and keep an eye on the big projectors that WE brought in. They did nothing but sit and get paid. And once we hit the 10 pm mark, we had to shut off ALL our cameras, or they got paid triple time. Mind you, they weren't DOING anything, but we had to shut OUR cameras down, which were run by OUR camera guys at 10 pm or else. We even had an unmanned camera that we left running and the two guys walked around, noticed the screen still on and made us turn it off.

Another time I was at a hotel in DC and we'd paid for a sound system, which included a small Mackie mixer. We didn't think it would be an issue, except that once there we were reminded we COULD NOT TOUCH the faders in case of feedback, and that if we wanted someone to do that, we had to PAY THEM to be there ALL day. I said screw it, I ran their board anyway and just kept an eye out for the moron who was their sound tech.

At almost every other venue that wasn't union, I've had no issues, the people are friendly and love their jobs. It's always the union slackers that are the problem. With job security, comes laziness and an hugh entitlement mentality. That's what's ruined unions.

August 08 2008 at 11:52 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Brian Peat's comment
hoode

It is true that Unions can be as corrupt as the companies. But the other way to look at this is the union contract was signed by a corporation somewhere.

Unions can abusive to be sure. But something MUST balance corporations whose only concern is bottom lines and abusing employees is a good if its good for that bottom line. Corporations wouldn't sign these contracts if they thought it would hurt them.

Unions wouldn't exist if corporations didn't abuse people.
Its a two edged sword.

August 09 2008 at 2:36 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Lars

It's weird some people in these comments actually pride themselves on their shitty working conditions. Makes me think about the Bush quote about a woman working three jobs to get by. "Uniquely American" or something asinine like that.

I'm glad to work under European labour laws: a good salary, work 40 hours, get paid 36 - which results in one paid day off every other week. Overtime is compensated in time, not cash, but it is compensated which is important.

I have a full schedule, and occassionally have inevitable overtime, but for the most part I can do what needs doing in the allotted time. Efficiency and productivity count in my job.

August 08 2008 at 8:08 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Lars's comment
james

amen! and then some!

August 08 2008 at 11:03 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Marcello

Ok, now we italians are usually accused of being lazy and like to do nothing all day long. But 40hrs a week are more or less the minimum work week here in italy. I have a very privileged contract and i have to work 37hrs a week. 85% of the workers here have 40hrs weeks...

I totally agree that overtime work MUST be payed but, man, think twice before accusing people of lazyness, next time! ;)

M

August 08 2008 at 4:13 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
manny

"Walsh alleges that Apple deliberately classified Walsh and others as management employees"
If its true that they didn't know thats how they were classified then apple might be in trouble, however when I was offered a job I was told it was salaried (with a higher pay) or i could take a lower hourly wage with the ability for overtime.

August 08 2008 at 1:39 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Cuban Techie

Good Im glad that cheap a$$ company is getting sued. As rich as they are and they don't even pay their employees well. I am an ex apple employee and Ill tell you right now that every word is true. They expected us to sell and push their stupid worthless features like mobile me and .mac without giving any compensation for it and on top of that they only hire part time to avoid benefits and all that topped off with a meager $10 an hour. And before that I was making bank with AT&T. I think every apple employee should sue the turtle neck off steve jobs. Im sorry but this is America and they are an American company. Look Im not asking for the stars and the moon just some honest days work and a salary to match the back breaking foot blistering, whip cracking work that they would make us do. Oh and my manager was the fatest hefer of a biotch to!!!

August 07 2008 at 11:28 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Weevie833

What no one has mentioned here so far is the toll on the "significant others" who are in committed relationships with those who feel obliged to work beyond normal hours on a regular basis. I have worked in commercial post-production for 18 years and have seen SO MANY divorces, break-ups, and screwed-up children of those who put work before family and relationships, either out of necessity or induced mania.

There are times to put in the extra hours, but as a policy of industry or of a company, it breeds nothing but resentment and destruction to important relationships. That is why I will never work in IT. I love my wife and kids AND I work my ass off, but not at the expense of what really matters in life.

This country has a real problem with this matter, IMO.

Steve C. - Syracuse, NY

August 07 2008 at 11:11 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Buy an ad here

Hot Apps on TUAW

Tweets

© 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.