What iOS 5 owes to jailbreak developers
There are a lot of apps that will be replaced -- or at least have some very heavy competition -- from the new features in iOS 5. It's easy to look around the App Store and see developers that have been 'Sherlocked' by Apple's inclusion of their functionality in the core OS; Twitter clients in particular are going to have a hard road ahead, and no-frills reminder apps are pretty much done for.
That's not the same thing as the wholesale borrowing that Apple has done from the jailbreak community with this new version of the OS, especially in the new notifications tools. Obviously, since JB devs tend to focus on new interaction methods and other system-level tweaks that would be off-limits to App Store products, there are more and different ideas about how the iPhone and iPad should work being tried and implemented there. That makes it fertile ground for Apple to see what does and doesn't work, and cherrypick the best ideas for internal use.
That may not be cool, but it's certainly in character for Apple to leverage third-party innovation in OS development, both on the Mac and on iOS. Here are a few examples of some noteworthy 'flattery' from Apple's iOS team to the jailbreak developers who broke trail.
One of the main reasons people jailbreak is to get better notifications and a useful lock screen; both issues Apple has finally addressed in a very big way in iOS 5. A few of the popular lock screen apps are David Ashman's LockInfo and Intelliborn's IntelliScreen, and both resemble (if they didn't inspire) iOS 5's new lock screen. In terms of notifications, Apple's taken aim at a couple of favorite JB apps: Notified and the recent MobileNotifier.
iCloud syncing looks like a fantastic backup system, so much so that EvilPenguin already feels that its backup tool iBye is no longer necessary. In fact, James Emrich, the developer behind EvilPenguin told TUAW: "iBye was a backup/restore manager for content. Basically what iCloud does without auto backups."
"With iOS 5, Apple continues the trend of cloning features and designs pioneered by myself and others into the OS itself. It is great to see these enhancements become available to millions of users, but it affects the ability of others to innovate on the platform independently of Apple."
I'm not sure it's entirely fair to say that Apple is simply cloning jailbreak apps; many JB apps are themselves inspired by apps and designs from other phone platforms. Still, the similarities to Apple's updates can be hard to swallow.
While jailbreaking and extra-SDK development has never been given Apple's imprimatur, it's also inarguable that iOS development as we know it could not have evolved as quickly or as successfully without the experience of the early jailbreak community. It's disingenuous for Apple to celebrate the innovations of iOS 5 without acknowledging that jailbreak devs had something to do with finding the way forward, but that's nothing new either.
In the end, the debut of iOS 5 might be problematic for jailbreaking developers and users mostly because some of the key reasons to jailbreak (notification improvements) are no longer relevant. Will I decide it's not worth it? I might. Looking at the list of new features, the only important thing missing for me is clipboard history (via Action Menu's Plus Pack).
Is custom theming, tweaks and better Wi-Fi tethering worth all the trouble of jailbreaking? It's possible that many people won't think so. Yes, there are people who jailbreak in order to pirate App Store apps, and they should knock that off, but there are others who do so simply to extend their devices' functionality in ways that iOS 5 is probably going to handle just as well.
That may not be cool, but it's certainly in character for Apple to leverage third-party innovation in OS development, both on the Mac and on iOS.
Subscribe to Newsletter
Software Updatesmore updates
- Readdle rolls out PDF Expert 5: iCloud support, shared folder with Documents by Readdle
- FlightTrack 5: new look and features just in time for holiday travel
- HBO Go for iOS update adds Google Chromecast support
- Haiku Deck updates iPad app, launches web-based cloud version
- Weather Underground iPhone app gets crowdsourced weather, iOS 7 style
- Apple updates iMovie, adds support for older Macs